Investment Commentary 24 April 2012 Policy & Stocks are linked
Market volitilty continues
After a couple of weeks of declines, markets managed to recover a bit last week, although they appear to remain mired in the same sloppy trading pattern they have been in for the last month. For the week, the Dow Jones Industrial Average gained 1.4% to 13,029 and the S&P 500 Index advanced 0.6% to 1,378. In contrast, the Nasdaq Composite fell 0.4% to 3,000 due in large part to a sharp decline in Apple’s stock price.
Global Outlook
To date, ECB liquidity provisions have removed some of the excessive pessimism surrounding the eurozone growth outlook. Meanwhile, other regions such as the US and Asia are broadly in line with investors’ generally positive growth expectations, albeit that risks generally remain on the downside. If commodity prices, such as oil, were to gain strongly from here, it could add to upside inflation risks; otherwise it is likely that inflation pressures will remain reasonably modest. Currency strength continues to be resisted by most countries – in some cases, actively so – and this is a sign that inflationary pressures remain modest.
Short-term interest rates remain at emergency levels in the US with the Fed intending to keep these levels until late 2014. Elsewhere, central banks are either neutral in their stance or have embarked on more easing measures. The ECB is officially on hold at the moment but another rate reduction can’t yet be ruled out at some stage this year. Nonetheless, low rates will also be maintained by it for some time to come.
Some stress has returned to peripheral bond markets following a period of outperformance versus German bonds. For instance, Spanish bonds have lost most of their recent out performance, while even French bonds have also underperformed of late. Irish bonds are dominated by an alarmingly positive consensus amongst bond investors (which is somewhat disconcerting). Investors, meanwhile, have ignored the Greek debt default and restructuring, something that could yet come back to influence market sentiment. The global backdrop – low short rates, central bank buying and disinflation concerns – suggests that long-term interest rates in major developed countries are likely to stay very low for a further considerable period of time.
Global equities in euro terms have risen by a very healthy 7.7% so far this year, although the recent market action has been softer. Valuations are reasonable but the markets’ strength was due to better macroeconomic sentiment rather than valuations or earnings. Investors have become a little cautious in the past month, driven by more even-handed economic data (rather than the earlier positive data bias) and the return of some nervousness regarding the sovereign/bank nexus in the eurozone. While US earnings’ data has been positive, negative eurozone developments are dominating sentiment in Europe for now. We had expected volatility to return at some stage and this remains the case.
Next Steps for Policymakers
Although the global economic and market backdrop certainly appears better than it did during the credit crisis, improvements have been slow and confidence remains shaken. Businesses, consumers and investors around the world are wary and remain on the lookout for signs of double dip recessions and market selloffs. While such attitudes are common during economic recoveries, the magnitude this time around appears well above normal. These attitudes are hardly surprising, given that deleveraging forces remain high and the global risks of deflation are still present. In this sort of environment, the onus is falling on policymakers to provide continued assurance that they are committed to erring on the side of reinflation until well after the economy has shifted into a self-sustaining expansion.
Since late in 2011, all of the world’s major central banks have clearly affirmed their resolve to sustain the economic recovery and keep interest rates low. The problem, however, is that central banks on their own cannot address all of the issues. In particular, many politicians and governments in Europe have been slower to act in helping to solve that region’s debt crisis. While some of the lack of decisive action can be blamed on ongoing election campaigns it is nonetheless disappointing. Since last year, the European Central Bank has been quite aggressive in terms of attempting to promote
liquidity, but the overall progress in that region has been slow and inconsistent.
Policy and Stocks Are Linked
Even a cursory look at stock market performance over the last several months shows how important global monetary and fiscal policy can be. The rally that started late last year and that persisted until about a month ago was triggered at least in part by the ECB’s announcements that it would become more aggressive in terms of promoting growth and liquidity. Taking a further look back, it seems clear that the 2010 downturn in stock prices ended when the Federal Reserve announced its QE2 program and the 2011 selloff was halted by some forceful action from both the Fed and the ECB.
The world’s central banks have drastically expanded their balance sheets and there is ample liquidity available. The issue is that this liquidity has been slow to move into the real economy since banks have been reluctant to lend and since private-sector credit demand has been weak. As the global economy continues to heal, however, money and credit growth is starting to improve (more so in the United States than in Europe or Japan), which is a positive sign.
Currencies
Strong earnings and economic data helped the appetite for risk and higher-yielding currencies to rise. This resulted in the €/$ rate ending the week at 1.32, 1% higher over the week.
Oil & gold
In commodity markets, oil gained as the week progressed as a result of economic data releases which caused speculation that European economies may be strengthening. The price ended the week at $103 a barrel, a marginal rise on the week. Gold finished the week over 1% lower.
Bonds
Spanish bonds fell for their seventh consecutive week as the G20 cited Europe’s debt crisis as the main threat to global growth. German bunds saw a weekly gain pared followed the release of stronger-than-expected data for the country. The Merrill Lynch over 5 year government bond index ended the week 0.5% lower
About
Neal Kelly is a Co-Founder and Director of Thomond Asset Management and can be contacted @ neal@thomondam.com